14:20:15
jberman:
In advance of the meeting today (I unfortunately won't be able to attend today), here is the latest proposed audit plan for the FCMP++ integration: https://github.com/seraphis-migration/monero/issues/294
14:20:58
jberman:
After discussions with @jeffro256 , we decided to open all crypto PR's upstream to the Monero master branch, and then we'd have those PR's audited. I'm currently finalizing those PR's, then will reach out to audit firms once ready (likely Cypher Stack)
14:21:23
jberman:
Re: alpha stressnet, all looks good for beta
14:21:23
jberman:
Re: beta stressnet, we're working through outstanding tasks still
14:27:18
sgp_:
No update from me other than money pls (re divisors)
14:39:29
plowsof:
ack
15:11:44
rucknium:
MRL meeting in this room in two hours.
16:24:28
jeffro256:
Unfortunately I am traveling today , so I also won't be able to make the meeting , but Cyperstack completed their audit of carrot_core! https://github.com/cypherstack/carrot_core-audit
16:59:23
rucknium:
Meeting time! https://github.com/monero-project/meta/issues/1343
16:59:32
rucknium:
1. Greetings
17:00:14
rucknium:
( @jberman:monero.social and @jeffro256:monero.social said they cannot attend the meeting today.)
17:01:23
rbrunner:
Hello
17:01:46
plowsof:
👋
17:01:59
rucknium:
This may be a short meeting 😄
17:02:19
rucknium:
2. Updates. What is everyone working on?
17:02:46
rbrunner:
Looking further into Polyseed implementations, with slow speed
17:03:19
rucknium:
me: For the next couple of weeks at least I won't have work updates. I need to reset, recharge, and return to my projects with fresher eyes. I will still chair MRL meetings, if that is ok with everyone.
17:03:55
rbrunner:
I would be very surprised if not :)
17:05:35
nioc:
rucknium please do <3
17:06:44
rucknium:
Sounds good :)
17:06:54
rucknium:
3. FCMP code integration audit overview (https://github.com/seraphis-migration/monero/issues/294).
17:07:18
rucknium:
I will quote @jberman:monero.social from before the meeting:
17:07:22
rucknium:
> In advance of the meeting today (I unfortunately won't be able to attend today), here is the latest proposed audit plan for the FCMP++ integration: https://github.com/seraphis-migration/monero/issues/294
17:07:35
rucknium:
> After discussions with @jeffro256 , we decided to open all crypto PR's upstream to the Monero master branch, and then we'd have those PR's audited. I'm currently finalizing those PR's, then will reach out to audit firms once ready (likely Cypher Stack)
17:08:55
rucknium:
Any comments on this plan?
17:09:41
rbrunner:
Looking from the outside, sounds reasonable, and personally I trust the persons involved to find a good path forward
17:11:07
rucknium:
4. carrot-core implementation audit (https://github.com/cypherstack/carrot_core-audit).
17:11:34
rucknium:
This was posted just yesterday. AFAIK, @jbabb:cypherstack.com was the lead person on this.
17:12:48
rbrunner:
5 pages? Well, maybe that all it needs ...
17:13:04
rucknium:
DataHoarder[m] might find the report interesting because DataHoarder has re-implemented a lot of CARROT in Go. I think.
17:13:56
rbrunner:
Well yes, if the audit compares code with the spec, and code is ok, the result really is a quite short report. No problem :)
17:15:47
rbrunner:
Does not mean at all of course that this comparison was only little work.
17:17:33
rucknium:
Any more comments on the audit report for now? It was just posted, so everyone can have time to digest and bring up opinions later if desired.
17:19:38
rucknium:
5. FCMP alpha stressnet (https://monero.town/post/6763165).
17:20:11
rucknium:
Quoting @jberman:monero.social :
17:20:13
rucknium:
> Re: alpha stressnet, all looks good for beta
17:20:13
rucknium:
> Re: beta stressnet, we're working through outstanding tasks still
17:21:24
rbrunner:
Can't comment, don't take part
17:21:43
rbrunner:
People seem to have fun however, judging from the talk in the room
17:23:08
rucknium:
I have the alpha stressnet blockchain size at 226 GB, unpruned . I will be glad when it's reset for beta stressnet 😁
17:24:50
rucknium:
Anything more on stressnet?
17:27:16
rucknium:
We can end the meeting here. Thanks everyone.
17:28:04
plowsof:
thanks Rucknium!
17:28:44
rbrunner:
+1
18:50:53
DataHoarder:
yeah. I think I have a few specifics missing but most is there. I'll read when I have some time
19:02:19
DataHoarder:
^ I had to cleanup and stopped running it, will be back for beta
19:04:48
DataHoarder:
randomx v2 is merged upstream, beta had an item for having commitments
19:04:50
DataHoarder:
would that also now also include v2 testing (if commitments make it to beta stressnet?)
19:15:09
jeffro256:
That's not a bad idea at all
19:15:34
jeffro256:
I imagine it would break p2pool, XMRIG , etc, though
19:16:38
jeffro256:
Doesn't @sech1 also maintain xmrig ? Is there a planned deadline for xmrig support ?
19:18:53
sech1:
v2 code is already in xmrig dev branch
19:19:21
sech1:
P2Pool also updated RandomX repo
19:27:18
jeffro256:
Perfect, I'll work on v2 support for beta stressnet then
20:42:49
sech1:
for v2 commitments, you'll also need to define where in the block template to put them, and add them to the "submit_block" RPC
20:43:37
sech1:
not block template, but the block itself. Commitment is not a part of block template/block hashing blob
21:31:50
DataHoarder:
> I imagine it would break p2pool
21:31:51
DataHoarder:
^ the one that can mine in stressnet is go-p2pool not main P2Pool yet :)
21:32:30
DataHoarder:
and I do have go-randomx supporting V2 (and would support RandomX new release if one comes too)
21:33:45
DataHoarder:
sech1 would swoop in later when carrot/targets have more or less stabilized, as also all the carrot stuff has to make it in onto p2pool
23:08:23
DataHoarder:
block header, yeah